| As stated by the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) - a generic drug is
identical, or bioequivalent to a brand name
drug in dosage form, safety, strength, route
of administration, quality, performance
characteristics and intended use. In other
words, pharmacological effects of generic
drugs are exactly the same as those of their
brand name counterparts. Generic version of
the drug has the same active ingredient with
the same chemical purity as the brand name
drug. However, trademark laws in the United
States do not allow the generic drug to look
exactly like the brand name drug. So other
ingredients such as tablet fillers, binders,
coatings, flavors, or colors usually are
different.
The major difference between brand name
and generic drug is the research process
required for the brand name company to
discover, design, and develop the new drug.
This process includes preclinical testing of
a new drug in laboratories, several phases
of clinical studies in volunteers and people
who have the disorder being studied and
finally FDA review and approval. The whole
process usually takes about 10 years and on
average can cost a drug company about $500
million.
The FDA grants the innovator company a
patent that gives the company an exclusive
right to a drug for 20 years. Additional
patents can sometimes be filed to extend the
patent life. After a patent has expired,
other companies are allowed to manufacture
and sell a generic version of the drug.
For the healthcare industry, generic
drugs offer significant savings to
consumers. According to the Congressional
Budget Office, generic drugs save consumers
an estimated $8 to $10 billion a year at
retail pharmacies. Potential savings are
even greater. American consumers could have
saved $20 billion in 2004, and even more
could be saved in 2005 and future years,
says a report released by Express Scripts
Inc.
Generic drugs are less expensive because
generic manufacturers donТt have the
investment costs of the developer of a new
drug and so they can sell their product at
substantial discounts. Also, when multiple
companies begin producing and selling
generic versions of the same brand name
drug, the competition among them also drives
the price down even further. Today, almost
half of all prescriptions are filled with
generic drugs.
Before generic drugs can be marketed,
they must be approved by the FDA. To start
approval process, generic company has to
submit Abbreviated New Drug Application
(ANDA) to the FDA.
The main stages of the generic drug
review process are the following:
Bioequivalence Review - this process
establishes that the proposed generic drug
is bioequivalent (within a few percentage
points) to the brand name drug. Generic drug
is bioequivalent to brand name drug if both
the rate and extent of absorption of the
active ingredient of the generic drug fall
within established parameters when compared
to that of the brand name drug.
Bioequivalence of different versions of a
drug can vary by up to 20%, because for most
drugs, such variations do not noticeably
alter effectiveness or safety. However,
actual differences between FDA approved
generics and brand name drugs are typically
only about 3.5% on average and rarely exceed
10%.
Chemistry/Microbiology review - this
process provides assurance that the generic
drug will be manufactured in a reproducible
manner under controlled conditions. Among
areas that are subject to check are
manufacturing procedures, raw material
specifications and controls, sterilization
process, container and closure systems.
Request for Plant Inspection - Upon
filing an ANDA an establishment evaluation
request is forwarded to the Office of
Compliance to determine whether or not every
link in the drug production chain is
operating in compliance with current Good
Manufacturing Practice regulations. Each
facility listed on the evaluation request is
evaluated individually and the Office of
Compliance makes an overall evaluation for
the entire application.
Labeling review - this process ensures
that the proposed generic drug labeling
(package insert, container, package label
and patient information) is identical to
that of the brand name drug except for
differences due to changes in the
manufacturer, distributor, pending
exclusivity issues, or other characteristics
inherent to the generic drug.
Based on the results of bioequivalence
review generic drug receives a two-letter
therapeutic equivalence evaluations code.
The coding system for therapeutic
equivalence evaluations is constructed to
allow users to determine whether the FDA has
evaluated a particular approved product as
therapeutically equivalent to other products
(first letter) and to provide additional
information on the basis of evaluations
(second letter).
Drugs are considered to be
therapeutically equivalents only if they
contain the same active ingredients, are of
the same route of administration and are
identical in strength or concentration, and
if they can be expected to have the same
clinical effect and safety profile.
The two basic categories into which drugs
have been placed are indicated by the first
letter as follows:
A - drug that FDA considers to be
therapeutically equivalent to other drugs.If
there are no known or suspected
bioequivalence problems, the generic drug
receives one of the following codes:
AA - Products in conventional dosage
forms not presenting bioequivalence problems
AN - Solutions and powders for
aerosolization
AO - Injectable oil solutions
AP - Injectable aqueous solutions
AT - Topical products (creams, gels,
lotions, oils, ointments, pastes, solutions,
sprays and suppositories)
AB - if actual or potential
bioequivalence problems have been resolved
with adequate evidence supporting
bioequivalence
B - drug that FDA, at this time,
considers not to be therapeutically
equivalent other pharmaceutically equivalent
products:
BC - Extended-release dosage forms
(capsules, injectables and tablets)
BD - Active ingredients and dosage forms
with documented bioequivalence problems
BE - Delayed-release oral dosage forms
BN - Products in aerosol-nebulizer drug
delivery systems
BP - Active ingredients and dosage forms
with potential bioequivalence problems
BR - Suppositories or enemas that deliver
drugs for systemic absorption
BS - Products having drug standard
deficiencies
BT - Topical products with bioequivalence
issues
BX - Drugs for which the data are
insufficient to determine therapeutic
equivalence
B* - Drugs requiring further FDA
investigation and review to determine
therapeutic equivalence
If the generic drug is placed into B
category this does not mean that it is not
good or is of lower quality. It simply means
that if you started using that generic, you
should not switch to the brand name or vice
versa especially if that drug has a narrow
therapeutic range (some antidepressants,
corticosteroid tablets, antihypertensive
drugs).
To ensure the quality of generic drugs,
FDA inspects facilities where drugs are
manufactured about 3,500 times a year. Both
brand name and generic drug facilities must
meet the same standards of good
manufacturing practices. FDA does not permit
drugs to be made in substandard facilities.
Manufacturers of generic drugs have
facilities comparable to those of
manufacturers of brand name drugs. In fact,
with the potential to lose millions of
dollars to a generic companies, some brand
name firms have either bought smaller
generic companies or created their own. FDA
estimates that 50% of generic drugs are
produced is by brand name companies. They
frequently make copies of their own drugs
but sell them under the generic name (e.g.
GlaxoSmithKline and Pfizer produce generic
versions of their own drugs Paxil and
Neurontin).
Not all brand name drugs have generic
versions. Sometimes a drug is too hard to
duplicate, or there are no adequate tests to
prove that the generic drug acts the same as
the brand name drug. Sometimes the market
for the drug is too small and there is no
business sense to create another version of
a drug. You can search for all generic
equivalents of brand name drugs by using the
"FDA Electronic Orange Book". |